Three legislators vie for tenure records in 2018 election

One of the nice things about having such a robust database here is the ability to quickly calculate records and dig into trends. Sometimes the data is straightforward, and sometimes it takes a bit of research to fully comprehend. Most of the time, though, its a mixed bag. For instance: Officially, only one State Senator in Indiana’s history has been elected to serve ten terms. Unofficially, and depending on which state government entity you believe, there may actually be two…but that’s a messy story that may soon be moot anyway, so let’s start with the straightforward data.

When Von Eichhorn (D-Wells) retired from the State Senate in 1966 after serving a then-record seven terms, a freshman legislator named Joe Harrison (R-Fountain) entered the chamber. Nobody would touch Eichhorn’s record until 1994, when Harrison was elected to an eighth term, followed by a ninth term in 1998, and–by default after no one filed to run against him in either the primary or the general–a tenth, and final, term from 2002-2006. It wouldn’t take as long for Harrison’s sole ownership of the record to be challenged: Larry Borst (R-Marion) ran for his tenth term in 2004, and Bob Garton (R-Columbus) did so in 2006; both, however, would lose their primaries. No one else had the opportunity to attempt a tenth term until 2014, but that year Johnny Nugent (R-Dearborn) opted to retire after nine terms rather than run for reelection.

And here is where things get a bit messy: Frank Mrvan (D-Lake) was also on the ballot in 2014. Officially, he won election to his ninth term that fall, but that November marked the tenth time he was sworn in to start a term. First elected in 1978, Mrvan faced a tough re-election battle after his fourth term in 1994. After the voting machines were tabulated on Election Day, his Republican challenger Sandy Dempsey (R-Lake) had a 110 vote lead. After the absentee ballots were counted, Mrvan was ahead by 54. Dempsey asked for a recount, and the State Board of Accounts invalidated a number of absentee ballots for various reasons, putting Dempsey back ahead by 9. The State Recount Commission, which had to certify the election results, decided some of those ballots shouldn’t have been invalidated, and ultimately certified a 50-vote victory for Mrvan. So Mrvan began the session as the 1st District Senator, but the issue wasn’t dead: Since the Senate has the power to seat it’s own members, a subcommittee was assembled to review the recount. They ultimately declared that Dempsey won by only three votes, and on January 19 the full Senate (by a voice vote, and with no Democrats present on the floor) unseated Mrvan and seated Dempsey. Mrvan would win the seat back in 1998 by about 500 votes (which, coincidentally, makes him the only Democrat since 1988 to win a Republican-controlled seat in the State Senate), thus getting a second shot at a fifth term.

So whether or not Mrvan won his ninth or tenth election in 2014, Harrison at least remains the only Senator to serve for 40 years. But since Mrvan has filed for reelection again this year, if he were to win and finish out his tenth full term, he would edge out Harrison’s record because he served at least a few months in 1994-95.  But he isn’t the only one looking to break Harrison’s record: Joe Zakas (R-St. Joseph), first elected in 1982, also filed for re-election. Because of a quirk of the calendar, Zakas would have a few extra days of service over Harrison at the end of his potential tenth term (though if both win in 2018, Mrvan’s extra bit of service keeps him in front of Zakas). Both have primary challengers this year, but sit in safe general election districts; if either is to be denied this record, the May election is likely going to be the harder hurdle to clear.

There’s no such legacy at stake in House races this year, nor is there any Mrvan/Dempsey-level drama clouding the picture. That’s mainly because Pat Bauer (D-St. Joseph) is already the longest serving member of that chamber (and possibly of any elected office in Indiana), and it isn’t even close. He faces no primary election challenger, and also sits in a safe general election district, meaning the odds are good for him to extend his record to a 25th term. Should he serve out that full term, he’d be the first legislator in either chamber to serve for 50 years, ten years after becoming the first House member ever to serve 40 years. Former Rep. Chet Dobis (D-Lake) was elected in 1970 with Bauer and also hit 40 years in 2010, but retired after 21 terms in 2012.  Bill Crawford (D-Marion) and Jeff Espich (R-Wells), who came into office just two years after Bauer and Dobis, each retired in 2012 after 20 terms. Nobody else currently has more than 18 terms in the House, though Charlie Brown (D-Lake) is retiring at the end of his current 18th term, and Sheila Klinker (D-Tippecanoe) is running for a 19th.

It’s not a coincidence, though, that most of the names mentioned up to this point served in the very recent past. While it’s easy to take for granted today, the idea of the General Assembly meeting every year is a relatively recent development. When Indiana ratified a new constitution in 1851, the legislature only met in odd-numbered years for about two months, unless there was reason for the Governor to call a special session. This led many to see the job not as a two- or four-year commitment, but as a two- or four-month commitment; as such, it wasn’t uncommon for most members to only serve a term or two, and then fade from public view.

That changed in 1970, when voters approved a constitutional amendment that set up our current long session/short session schedule. Meeting every year, combined with the advent of Organization Day each November, summer study committees, and a rash of special sessions in the 1980s and 1990s (from 1987 through 1997, five of the six long sessions required a special session to enact a budget; in 1991, it took two special sessions) led to the job of a state legislator being viewed as a constant, year-round commitment.

That change in perception ultimately led to a change in how (and how long) legislators served. Before 1970, the average length of service was just over 2 years (1 term) in the House, and just shy of 4 years (1 term) in the Senate (note: from 1816 to 1851, House terms were one year and Senate terms were three years, dragging down the averages). For those elected for the first time in 1970 or later, though, the average has almost tripled to nearly 6 years (3 terms) in the House, and almost doubled to 7 years (just shy of 2 terms) in the Senate. For those currently in office, the average jumps to over 10 1/2 years in the House, and just over 9 years in the Senate–though it should be noted that the average dropped by almost a full year with the resignations of Luke Kenley (R-Hamilton) and Brandt Hershman (R-Tippecanoe).

Given that the average length of service has seen such a stark increase over the past few decades, it shouldn’t be surprising to see so many recent names at the top of the tenure lists.  In fact, in the House, 17 of the 21 longest serving members were elected in 1970 or later; of the four remaining, three served the bulk of their service in the post-1970 era. Only Glenn Slenker never served in the modern era. In the Senate, we see similar numbers: 16 of the top 20 were elected in 1970 or later; two more were elected in 1968, and were still in their first term when the 1970 reforms came into effect; and one more served the bulk of his service post-1970. Only Eichhorn never served in the era. The numbers are more striking if we limit it to only the top 10: 9 of 10 in the House served in the post-1970 era, and all 10 in the Senate did so.

For those of us who love seeing historical records set, seeing both Mrvan and Zakas on the verge of overtaking Harrison’s record, or Bauer set to become the first member of the 50-year Club, adds another layer of intrigue to an already fascinating election year. But as long as the average length of tenure trends continue upwards, expect more and more legislators to compete for their slots on the All-Time lists.

Selected Bibliography

  • Capitol & Washington Length of Tenure Records for state legislators: http://www.capitolandwashington.com/records/tenure/ILegislative/
  • McIntyre, Larry. “Hammond Demo keeps Senate seat in recount”, published in the Indianapolis Star on December 20, 1994
  • “Panel will review disputed state Senate race”, published in the Indianapolis Star on December 31, 1994
  • “Mrvan-Dempsey recount battle likely to continue”, published in The Times of Northwest Indiana on January 21, 1995

 

 

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Latest Database Updates

Latest Blog Posts

Hoosiers to Know