| Danny Basham | George T. Holland | Bruce W. Peavler | Ralph Spelbring | Barry Welsh | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bartholomew | 877 (19.48%) | 1,171 (26.00%) | 482 (10.70%) | 354 (7.86%) | 1,619 (35.95%) |
| Dearborn | 551 (27.56%) | 494 (24.71%) | 214 (10.71%) | 209 (10.46%) | 531 (26.56%) |
| Decatur | 181 (15.66%) | 266 (23.01%) | 88 (7.61%) | 101 (8.74%) | 520 (44.98%) |
| Delaware | 3,049 (28.12%) | 1,716 (15.82%) | 1,557 (14.36%) | 753 (6.94%) | 3,769 (34.76%) |
| Fayette | 331 (18.55%) | 322 (18.05%) | 110 (6.17%) | 120 (6.73%) | 901 (50.50%) |
| Franklin | 200 (20.37%) | 178 (18.13%) | 88 (8.96%) | 85 (8.66%) | 431 (43.89%) |
| Hancock | 580 (17.54%) | 1,161 (35.11%) | 423 (12.79%) | 288 (8.71%) | 855 (25.85%) |
| Henry | 466 (14.67%) | 564 (17.75%) | 542 (17.06%) | 231 (7.27%) | 1,374 (43.25%) |
| Jefferson | 973 (40.80%) | 353 (14.80%) | 146 (6.12%) | 118 (4.95%) | 795 (33.33%) |
| Jennings | 413 (29.71%) | 254 (18.27%) | 152 (10.94%) | 143 (10.29%) | 428 (30.79%) |
| Ohio | 104 (31.52%) | 82 (24.85%) | 24 (7.27%) | 28 (8.48%) | 92 (27.88%) |
| Randolph | 281 (21.90%) | 226 (17.61%) | 120 (9.35%) | 124 (9.66%) | 532 (41.47%) |
| Ripley | 294 (24.87%) | 267 (22.59%) | 98 (8.29%) | 133 (11.25%) | 390 (32.99%) |
| Rush | 136 (16.83%) | 242 (29.95%) | 73 (9.03%) | 56 (6.93%) | 301 (37.25%) |
| Scott | 789 (64.30%) | 172 (14.02%) | 65 (5.30%) | 40 (3.26%) | 161 (13.12%) |
| Shelby | 414 (19.60%) | 569 (26.94%) | 273 (12.93%) | 180 (8.52%) | 676 (32.01%) |
| Switzerland | 209 (33.12%) | 104 (16.48%) | 43 (6.81%) | 55 (8.72%) | 220 (34.87%) |
| Union | 42 (13.73%) | 64 (20.92%) | 44 (14.38%) | 25 (8.17%) | 131 (42.81%) |
| Wayne | 584 (16.88%) | 646 (18.68%) | 355 (10.26%) | 342 (9.89%) | 1,532 (44.29%) |