| James Baird | Joseph W. Mackey | |
|---|---|---|
| Benton | 3,013 (74.75%) | 1,018 (25.25%) |
| Boone | 12,223 (73.12%) | 4,494 (26.88%) |
| Carroll | 7,179 (76.10%) | 2,255 (23.90%) |
| Cass | 10,236 (68.61%) | 4,684 (31.39%) |
| Clinton | 9,399 (73.95%) | 3,311 (26.05%) |
| Fountain | 6,164 (78.62%) | 1,676 (21.38%) |
| Hendricks | 56,411 (65.21%) | 30,094 (34.79%) |
| Howard | 21,863 (64.04%) | 12,275 (35.96%) |
| Jasper | 11,406 (75.34%) | 3,733 (24.66%) |
| Montgomery | 13,018 (77.43%) | 3,795 (22.57%) |
| Morgan | 9,133 (78.07%) | 2,566 (21.93%) |
| Newton | 4,909 (76.33%) | 1,522 (23.67%) |
| Putnam | 12,594 (76.96%) | 3,771 (23.04%) |
| Tippecanoe | 36,476 (51.80%) | 33,940 (48.20%) |
| Warren | 3,426 (78.01%) | 966 (21.99%) |
| White | 8,081 (73.70%) | 2,884 (26.30%) |