| Benjamin Frederick | Joseph W. Mackey | Howard Joseph Pollchick | Veronikka M. Ziol | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Benton | 50 (18.05%) | 141 (50.90%) | 12 (4.33%) | 74 (26.71%) |
| Boone | 159 (13.14%) | 611 (50.50%) | 33 (2.73%) | 407 (33.64%) |
| Carroll | 137 (17.19%) | 408 (51.19%) | 36 (4.52%) | 216 (27.10%) |
| Cass | 250 (16.98%) | 793 (53.87%) | 69 (4.69%) | 360 (24.46%) |
| Clinton | 142 (16.23%) | 489 (55.89%) | 37 (4.23%) | 207 (23.66%) |
| Fountain | 94 (18.47%) | 278 (54.62%) | 19 (3.73%) | 118 (23.18%) |
| Hendricks | 1,010 (12.69%) | 4,273 (53.67%) | 244 (3.06%) | 2,434 (30.57%) |
| Howard | 665 (16.73%) | 1,969 (49.52%) | 246 (6.19%) | 1,096 (27.57%) |
| Jasper | 246 (20.00%) | 602 (48.94%) | 88 (7.15%) | 294 (23.90%) |
| Montgomery | 225 (19.98%) | 502 (44.58%) | 83 (7.37%) | 316 (28.06%) |
| Morgan | 125 (17.17%) | 318 (43.68%) | 31 (4.26%) | 254 (34.89%) |
| Newton | 91 (19.57%) | 206 (44.30%) | 47 (10.11%) | 121 (26.02%) |
| Putnam | 138 (12.13%) | 664 (58.35%) | 37 (3.25%) | 299 (26.27%) |
| Tippecanoe | 995 (9.35%) | 6,192 (58.16%) | 288 (2.71%) | 3,171 (29.79%) |
| Warren | 22 (8.37%) | 182 (69.20%) | 9 (3.42%) | 50 (19.01%) |
| White | 135 (15.79%) | 458 (53.57%) | 49 (5.73%) | 213 (24.91%) |