| # | Office Holder | Party | Tenure |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | William Hendricks | Dec 11, 1816 to Jul 25, 1822 | |
| Vacant | Jul 25, 1822 to Dec 2, 1822 | ||
| 2 | Jonathan Jennings | Dec 2, 1822 to Mar 4, 1823 | |
| 3 | Godlove Stein Orth | Republican | Mar 4, 1873 to Mar 4, 1875 |
| William Williams | Republican | Mar 4, 1873 to Mar 4, 1875 |